12 Dec 2016 15:55:37
Goalkeeper very indecisive Cash young and may progress to be a good player but not a full back Mills and Perquis solid but always prone to a mistake Eric not a left back Mancienne not a midfielder but a very good sweeper being played out of position to accommodate Perquis Kasami very poor can't pass the ball and is too slow. Lam, not a midfielder . Thinks He is better than He is. Bendtner past his best.

Caryol not up to standard passing poor and so is his judgement as to who to pass it to Osbourne The only player to keep going for the whole game. PM might be a good manager but needs to adapt to the EFL ways of playing.


1.) 12 Dec 2016
12 Dec 2016 17:04:45
Not much I disagree with there 1978. How Vaughan can't get a start is beyond me. Lam and Kasami offer very little.


2.) 12 Dec 2016
12 Dec 2016 17:32:40
agree - Kasami, Lam, Carayol extremely poor. Bendtner average. Vaughan and Hobbs are better than any of these but the manager doesn't fancy them. Without Assombalonga and Lansbury we look unimpressive. Could have lost by more, at least Cash and Osborn gave it a go. Get rid of the deadweights and bring in some more youth players, they couldn't be any worse.


3.) 12 Dec 2016
12 Dec 2016 20:07:18
Carayol shouldn't wear the Garibaldi again. He never broke into a sweat. Either he's got a fitness problem or somebody needs to explain to him what a sheep v Forest match means.


4.) 12 Dec 2016
12 Dec 2016 20:57:38
If Carayol was any good we would not have got him on a free transfer from Boro
As with Bendtner if He was any good He wold have found a bigger club than ours
The same could be said for Mills Perquis Storkavich, Lam Licha
It seems like we are a dumping ground for the sick and elderly. I wonder if Fawaz had done a deal with Dept for work and pensions.


5.) 13 Dec 2016
13 Dec 2016 10:39:55
What did you expect for a bunch of freebies? Unfortunately we are in a position where we can't spend millions on players like derby can. A bit harsh to criticise them all against a better side. Kasami and Carayol are probably the two I agree most on, Kasami is one of the worst CMs I've ever seen. I still think Bendtner has potential, and at times has shown his brilliance, but there's only so much a lone striker can do. He's only just come back from injury too, remember.


6.) 13 Dec 2016
13 Dec 2016 14:39:43
Derby were not much better than us an own goal a mistake by a full back that is not a left back and a shot that the goalie did not hang on to
Team selection was all wrong and attitude in the second half was very poor.